Can I suggest that your readers warn their insurers immediately of anything suspicious which could be a scam?

My daughter and I run a small business delivering livestock feed in the South East using Land Rovers and trailers. We each cover around 30,000 miles per year. Some months ago my daughter returned to the yard and reported a 'strange' incident involving her vehicle and two other cars on the M23. The upshot of the incident was that the driver of the second of the two other vehicles seemed to indicate to my daughter that damage to the front of her vehicle had been caused by the rear of my daughters trailer (whilst she was travelling at close to 60mph). The other driver did not stop, but sped away.

After hearing my daughter's report I immediately called my insurers and ensured that they logged the date and time of the call and made a brief note of the incident. Some days later I had a letter from the police suggesting that the driver of my vehicle had failed to stop/report a road traffic accident. A statement was sent to the police along with the driver's name, and again when my daughter received communication from the police. The police are taking no further action.

As a result of my daughter’s detailed statement recorded at the time, and my notification to the insurers before the fraudulent claim was lodged (which includes personal injury claims), the whole incident is being treated as a fraudulent claim from the outset. The moral of this story - notify your insurers immediately of anything suspicious so that they have a chance to properly investigate the circumstances.

Asked on 14 January 2012 by NH, via email

Answered by Honest John
Fair warning.
Similar questions
I learned in April 2013 that my then insurer had paid out on a claim from someone who alleged I had damaged their vehicle in 2011. I was not aware of this claim, still less given an opportunity to contest...
In June 2009 I parked my wife's Saab convertible between two empty spaces in a shop car park. When I returned, the space on the Saab's driving side had been taken by a large SUV type vehicle. It was parked...
I have been following your correspondence concerning "Claims Management" and whiplash scams. Can you give advice what to do at the time of an incident, please? Is it possible to deter the other party...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer