A dealer won't give me any more than £8000 for my Audi A6 against a BMW Z4 - is he trying it on?

I have a 2005 55-plate Audi A6 Avant 2.7 TDI S-Line with full leather, Hi-line MMI, 11 months MoT and FSH with 90,000 miles. I have today been to BMW Stafford to test drive a 54-plate 2004 BMW Z4 3.0 SE auto with 51,000 miles. They want £12,990 for the Z4 and have offered me £8000 for the Audi. I have been on Glass' website and it says part-exchange values for the Z4 are £10,800 and for the Audi £9200. The dealer won't budge and has said I can't go by Glass's guide, and still wants £5000 plus the Audi in part-ex. Is he trying it on?

Asked on 14 May 2010 by Jack Regan

Answered by Dan Harrison
Hello. It depends how keen the dealer is to have your A6 Avant. It's coming up for five years old, which means it's touch-and-go whether the dealer would want to retail it - assuming it's a main dealer. If he wasn't retailing it, it's likely that it would be sold to another dealer, an independent, or auctioned - which is reflected in the price you've been offered. Also, have you mileage-adjusted the Glass's Guide price? 90,000 miles is a little high (though not excessively so) for this age of car. If you haven't, you may find the Glass's price is closer to the one the dealer is offering. You'll get a much better price if you sell privately. There's a reasonably strong market for your car.
Similar questions
I am set on buying a used Porsche 911. While I love the classic 993, the price for a good one is approaching that of an early 997. For this reason, I have decided to look for one up to four years old,...
How much difference does low mileage make to a car's price? Is there a rule of value added per 1000 miles under average mileage and if so, what is it?
What price should I get for a 2011 (March - 5300 miles only) manual Freelander GS as a trade in against a new Porsche Boxter? I do not want a hard ride so what wheel size is the best for the Porsche?
Related models
Stunning looking and practical executive estate. At its best with quattro 4WD and the excellent 3.0 TDI engine.
Better looking and a sportier drive than its Z3 predecessor.