Mix and martching winter and summer tyres

Recently, you confirmed that a winter tyre can be used as a 'spare' in the summer; or a summer tyre can be used in the winter; provided it is treated in the same way as a space-saver, and kept below 50mph. What if the two sets of tyres are on different wheels, eg 16-inch winter rims, and 17-inch summer ones?

Same overall diameter tyre, of course, to compensate for the different rim sizes. I can see no reason why your answer shouldn't be the same, but would appreciate your guidance.

Asked on 6 January 2013 by John Garside

Answered by Honest John
Obviously not advisable, but if treated with great caution then could be used to get you to a place of refuge. It's the case with my FIAT 500 on 14" winter tyres and 15" summer tyres. Same space saver spare.
Similar questions
I am driving to SW France, to a remote mountain/hill region, at altitude up to approx 800-1000m. There is a steep and winding road to and from the house. I asked about fitting winter tyres, but garage...
Please can you tell me if it is okay to leave winter tyres on all year round? I have read that they out perform 'normal tyres' at below 7 degrees, but do they wear particularly quickly at higher temperature?...
Five weeks ago I bought a used 2005 Fiesta from a Ford Dealer. I have just noticed that one of the rear tyres is rated for winter, and the others all summer. Could this be dangerous under heavy braking...